Ray Malone's Commentary

Recent Columns

Current Column

16 Year Cycle & Obama

Obama in Florida

Long Shots frm Obama

The lies have it

Rove the Boat

Campaign Status

Media Bias

Obama's Plight

What voters are saying

Obama Messiah 

Can Victory bring Defeat

Assuming the Position

Gross Vs interNet

Obama needs changing

Desperation Revealed

The current situation

I Dreamed of Genie

Fighting the Last Election

It don't mean a thing

3 Cheers for the Liberal media

Building an Army

The lessons of History

Republican Primary

Old Hampshire

Hillary Strategy

Political Ads and Why

Hillary's Problem

Expectations

Elite Ignorance

Computers and Hieroglyphics

Anti-Abortion A MUST

Fight For GOP

Newt or Consequences

Winning The Presidency

Fringe On Top

Hsu City Hsu

Fighting Lost Battles

Sleeper Cells

Democratic leaders believe

Play Nice

Electing Hillary

Winning Moderate Votes

The Lesson of Nam

Karl Rove Resigns

Parties never learn

Life or Death

Why the Stupid Party

Stupid Party

Hillary's Staffers

 Military Change In Iraq

The New Iraqi Plan

Iraqi System of Justice

Pres Bush and the Media

The voters Views

Building an Army

Republicans Not Voting

Political Motivation

Breaking New Ground

Signs along the way

Immigration Vs Corruption

Giving our Enemies

The Base Debased

The Nomination Curse

Alito .. an Exercise

A first look 2008

A Bad Democratic Year

Building an Army in Iraq

I'll See Your Doom

What Did Fitzmas Know

It's Beging to look like Fitzmas

No Trust

Miers Or Less

Roberts Confirmation

Playing with life and death

Watch Dogs Didn't Bark

UpChuck Hagel

Dumber than an Ox...ley.

All the Times is fit to print

The Hill You Say!

2008 .. Dinos and Dinosaurs

Leaking in private

Democrat Speech Defect

Watergate Lessons

Sneddon's Moon Walk

Democrat Motto

I never FELT that way

Defense Against Terrorism

I'll Never No Ya

Hillary and Change

I Herd That!!!

They don't know us

Thumbs Up

History of the Filibuster

Welcome Arab Terrorists

The Royal Flush

Can I Wedge In Here

Changing names

Party Transistion

Better to be a Minority

Why moral issues are a disaster

Killing the Innocent

Never Again

Rather Vs Nixon

Democrats Decline

Europe  Bushwhacked

Point Of Order

Who Lied and why

Dang Democrats have misunderstimated again

The Boxer Byrd Strategy

Bush Vs. CBS

The Way things Were

The Roots of Wrong

Reid my Daschled Hopes

Cabinets.. and the MSM

Democrats Didn't Register

Results... More Results

Up Main Stream No Paddle

Pundits-- togo Box

Powell Right in the kisser

Media News Bosses

Cooking the Media Medium Rare

See your Post and Raise a Mortem

Hmm 1st For then Against

Midwest is turning Red

Did Mason move Dixon

When Grant Took Richmond

Debates and Rebates

The Decline and fall of Dan Rather

Delphi Code

 

 

 

Breaking New Ground

Aug 21, 2006

I have been puzzled by the pollsters sometimes sampling Democrats and Republicans equally and then within months under sampling Republicans. I started looking for a reason. They are pretty sure what Democratic turn out will be. It is a trend line. But they have to be making educated guesses at Republican turn out.

From 1980 through 2004 the Democratic turn out in presidential elections has been. 35, 37, 41, 44, 47, 51 and 59 million voters. That is a consistent pattern of turn out. On the other hand Republican turn out over the same years has been 43, 54, 48, 39, 39, 50, and 62 million. Consider that the Perot vote fell from 19 million in 1992 to just 10 million in 1998, yet the Republican vote did not change.

It may not be enough to predict a trend, but the 2000 and 2004 Republican returns paralleled the Democratic returns. However in the preceding 20 years  Republican turn outs were up and down and all around.

I think I can explain it as the Karl Rove effect.

I grew up in a Democratic family heavily engaged in the grass roots efforts of that party. The Democrats had a superb if not entirely legal ground game. I was shocked when I first got involved in Republican politics. There was no ground game ... at least not in Ohio.

I remember when I first got involved in a Republican Mayoral race back in the 1970s. I laid out a grass routes plan for use in the campaign. A local Republican told me in no uncertain terms that I was not from HIS County. He added I certainly did not understand how things worked in HIS county. His candidate got the crap beat out of him largely due to the Democrat's ground game.  His attitude was sort of like REAL GENTLEMEN don't do ground games.

But then came Karl Rove. And volunteers were organized into something approaching the precinct captains order I had known in the Democratic party. Voter lists were kept. Serious efforts made to get out the vote. That continues. I don't think we will see the up and down turnouts of 20 the century in the Republican party from now on.  Karl Rove has seen to that.

This historically bumpy road of Republican turn outs  may be how the pollsters are justifying the under sampling of Republican voters. They can predict the Democratic turn out. They are just educated guessing at the Republican turn out.

But the times they are a changing. The Democrat grass roots efforts have always  depended on someone paying for the turn out labor. And for the most of the 20th Century Democratic grass roots get out the vote effort was provided by Union Labor.

 But as labor unions have decreased in size and influence the number of shop stewards used to get out the vote has greatly decreased. And the government worker unions are not nearly as astute at getting out the vote.

The 2004 election may have been the high water mark for Democrats  in mid-western industrial states. There seems to me to bee a good chance that the 21st century will portray rapidly growing Republican trend lines, while the Democratic trend line may become erratic.

Bush won Ohio in 2004 due largely to the Republican volunteers registering 80,000 new voters. Such things as the last 72 hour push, and well manned phone banks did not exist years ago.   If a good grass roots effort is made this year, Republicans can continue their winning ways.

The days  when 43 million Republican voters in 1980  rose to 54 million in 1984 only to fall to 48 million in 1988 and fall to 39 million in 1992 are over.

Democrats have a finite base growing at consistent rate while Republicans have been a wavy line all over the map. Those who fail to consider what Karl Rove has wrought do not understand that he has given Republicans a ground game.

Lack of  a ground game explains the wavy line of the Republicans voter turn out. The pollsters may give Rove lip service, but they still do not understand what he has wrought. On the other hand pollsters may not have clearly seen the reason for the Democrat trend line and perhaps are unaware of the chance it may soon collapse.

We need to welcome them to the 21st Century.